Turkey Hits Back At Germany After Armenian Genocide Vote


ISTANBUL — Turkey recalled its ambassador to Germany on Thursday following a high-profile vote in Germany’s parliament that formally recognized the 1915 mass killings of Armenians by Ottoman Turks as genocide. 

The vote also places blame on Germany — which allied with the Ottomans in World War I — for failing to prevent the deaths of an estimated 1.5 million Armenians at that time.

Over a century later, the events widely known as the Armenian Genocide are still embroiled in controversy and hold significant political weight.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said on Thursday that German lawmakers’ nearly unanimous decision would “seriously affect relations” between the two countries. Erdogan’s relationship with Germany has deteriorated in recent months, and he made his fury over the vote known.

Turkey’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs accused Germany on Thursday of attempting to “alienate [Turks in Germany] from their own history and self-identity.” 

Recalling Hüseyin Avni Karslioglu, the Turkish ambassador to Germany, was only a “first step,” Erdogan said. Ankara also reportedly summoned its charge d’affaires from Berlin on Thursday.

If Germany is to be deceived by this, then bilateral, diplomatic, economic, trade, political and military ties — we are both NATO countries — will be damaged.Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan

Erdogan has offered muted condolences for the 1915 killings, saying that there were indeed events with “inhumane consequences” during World War I, but Turkey wholly denies the murders ever amounted to genocide. The Turkish state has also slammed critics for not paying more attention to the ethnic Turks who also died during that time.

Armenians, on the other hand, say the massacre fits every definition of the word genocide.

Men, women and children were forced on death marches, starved, raped and buried in mass graves just because they were Armenian, descendants of victims and survivors say.

The genocide is not forgotten,” said 95-year-old Mari Tomasyan, who told The WorldPost last year that dozens of her family members were marched toward the Syrian Desert to their deaths in 1915. “It’s impossible to forget.”

Armenians killed by Ottoman Turks during the Armenian Genocide in 1915.Universal History Archive/Getty Images
Armenians killed by Ottoman Turks during the Armenian Genocide in 1915.

While Armenians welcomed Germany’s decision to label the killings as genocide, it’s not clear how the resulting political spat between Germany and Turkey will affect other groups, like Syrian refugees.

Both Turkey and Germany are key players in the international effort to address the refugee crisis as millions of Syrians flee to neighboring countries and risk dangerous sea passages to Europe.

Turkey hosts more Syrian refugees than any other country, with over 2.7 million Syrians seeking refuge on Turkish soil. Meanwhile, roughly 1.1 million migrants arrived in Germany last year, many of them from Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan.

Turkey’s spat with Germany casts further doubt on the fate of the controversial and already-shaky EU-Turkey deal to manage the crisis. As part of the deal — which rights groups say is illegal and inhumane — Turkey has agreed to take back migrants who illegally cross the Aegean Sea to Greece.

The EU has promised to resettle one Syrian refugee in Europe in exchange for every migrant Turkey takes in, and has also pledged some 6 billion euros to help Turkey bear the financial burden of caring for millions of Syrian refugees.

An Armenian woman lights a candle in Jerusalem on April 24, 2015, during a mass marking the 100th anniversary of the ArmAmir Cohen/Reuters
An Armenian woman lights a candle in Jerusalem on April 24, 2015, during a mass marking the 100th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide.

It remains to be seen whether the German vote will impact the EU-Turkey deal. German Chancellor Angela Merkel attempted on Thursday to downplay the vote and its potential for political consequences. 

There is a lot that binds Germany to Turkey, and even if we have a difference of opinion on an individual matter, the breadth of our links, our friendship, our strategic ties, is great,” Merkel said.

Germany is far from the first EU country to recognize the 1915 massacre as a genocide — 11 out of 28 EU members now use the label to describe the mass killing of Armenians. Over 20 countries formally recognize the Armenian Genocide. That list does not include the United States.